Attention San Francisco Renters! What the Passing of Prop F Means for You

Although this comes as no surprise to most Bay Area residents, San Francisco is the most expensive city for new renters in the United States.1  The opportunity for profits has motivated unscrupulous landlords to engage in all types of nefarious behaviors to displace otherwise law-abiding tenants from coveted rent-controlled apartments.  These behaviors often culminate in the filing of unlawful detainer (eviction) lawsuits on frivolous grounds, such as the infamous case brought by two tech workers against a San Francisco special education school teacher on the ground that the use of gas and electrical appliances in her in-law unit constituted a “nuisance.”

Each year, hundreds of San Francisco tenants find themselves fighting eviction lawsuits.  The San Francisco Residential Rent Stabilization and Arbitration Board’s 2018 Annual Eviction Report indicates that between March 1, 2017 and March 1, 2018, 1,657 San Francisco renters received eviction notices.  Although organizations like the Eviction Defense Collaborative2 and the Justice & Diversity Center3 have, to date, provided needed eviction defense services to low-income renters, many nonetheless lose their homes by failing to respond to unlawful detainer complaints in time—even in cases where the purported “just cause” for eviction is meritless.  In short, landlords in these cases prevail because they have the power and the resources to hire savvy eviction attorneys—not because the law is on their side.  Some tenants, unaware of their rights and fearful of having an eviction on their record, simply move out.

Until recently, New York was the only city in the country to provide taxpayer-funded full scope legal representation to tenants in eviction cases.  However, on June 5, 2018, San Francisco voters passed Proposition F by a margin of 55.74% to 44.26%, making San Francisco the second city in the United States to provide tenants facing eviction with the right to taxpayer-funded eviction defense counsel.

Under the new law, the City & County of San Francisco is required to create, finance, and manage a program that makes legal counsel available to residential tenants served with notices of eviction or an upcoming lawsuit to evict them.  These tenants must be provided with an attorney within thirty days from the date an eviction notice is served or upon service of an unlawful detainer complaint—whichever comes first.  Under Proposition F, representation will be supplied “at least until such time that the eviction notice or unlawful detainer complaint is withdrawn, the case is dismissed, or a judgment in the matter is entered.”  Full scope representation will be provided by a designated organization or attorney and this representation includes filing responsive pleadings, appearing on behalf of the tenant in court proceedings, and providing legal advice.  The Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development has twelve months to formalize a plan to serve all San Francisco residents.  For more information on Proposition F, click here.

Whether your landlord is refusing to make necessary repairs in your rental unit, failing to remediate unsafe conditions, or filing a retaliatory eviction lawsuit against you, contact Tenant Law Group to learn more about your rights and remedies.



The Eviction Defense Collaborative (EDC) is the principal organization in San Francisco helping low-income tenants respond to eviction lawsuits.  Each year, the EDC provides emergency legal services and rental assistance to over 5,000 San Francisco tenants. Tenant Law Group’s CEO & Managing Attorney Eric Toscano serves on the EDC’s Board of Directors.

The Justice & Diversity Center (JDC) oversees two important programs to protect renters.  The Eviction Defense Project provides legal representation to clients during their eviction proceedings.  The Housing Negotiation Project provides low-income individuals and families wit volunteer attorneys during their mandatory settlement conferences.

The following two tabs change content below.

Tenant Law Group, PC

Here at Tenant Law Group, we dedicate one hundred percent of our practice to representing Bay Area renters. Whether you have been harassed, endured uninhabitable living conditions, or lost a rent-controlled unit without legal justification, we are here to fight for you, because we know a knowledgeable and aggressive tenant lawyer can mean the difference between having a roof over one’s head and being homeless.

Latest posts by Tenant Law Group, PC (see all)